banner-image
banner-image
banner-image
banner-image
Anthropologie Fotini Tikkou Santa Claus Mug Cup Matching Plate Set Cookie Milk

Anthropologie Fotini Tikkou Santa Claus Mug Cup Matching Plate Set Cookie Milk

$65.00$32.50

Illuminated Santa Milk and Cookie Tray with Sign

Illuminated Santa Milk and Cookie Tray with Sign

$71.42$35.71

Winnie The Pooh A Christmas To Remember Cookies and Milk For Santa Dish Set 1999

Winnie The Pooh A Christmas To Remember Cookies and Milk For Santa Dish Set 1999

$35.00$17.50

Milk & Cookies For Santa Stoneware 2pc Set Bottle & Plate 8.5” Christmas Table

Milk & Cookies For Santa Stoneware 2pc Set Bottle & Plate 8.5” Christmas Table

$20.00$10.00

Santa Themed Cookie Plate and Mug. Leave Cookies and Milk for Santa! Set.

Santa Themed Cookie Plate and Mug. Leave Cookies and Milk for Santa! Set.

$15.95$7.97

HEARTH AND HAND WITH MAGNOLIA MILK & COOKIES PLATE & MUG SET FOR SANTA NEW

HEARTH AND HAND WITH MAGNOLIA MILK & COOKIES PLATE & MUG SET FOR SANTA NEW

$19.99$9.99

Waterford Holiday Heirlooms Milk & Cookies for Santa St Nick Mug

Waterford Holiday Heirlooms Milk & Cookies for Santa St Nick Mug

$29.99$14.99

Rae Dunn Milk and Cookies mug plate red magenta

Rae Dunn Milk and Cookies mug plate red magenta

$29.99$14.99

EXCELLENT Mary Engelbreit Cookies and Milk For Santa Plate and Mug Box ME INK

EXCELLENT Mary Engelbreit Cookies and Milk For Santa Plate and Mug Box ME INK

$35.00$17.50

LEGO Milk Cookies Pastries Sweets Plate FRUIT FOOD Party Favor Afterschool Snack

LEGO Milk Cookies Pastries Sweets Plate FRUIT FOOD Party Favor Afterschool Snack

$8.33$4.17

Artisan Dollhouse Miniature Milk Bottle Chocolate Chip Cookies 1:12 Food OOAK

Artisan Dollhouse Miniature Milk Bottle Chocolate Chip Cookies 1:12 Food OOAK

$10.00$5.00

2022 Disney Star Wars Blue Milk and Cookies Set! New in Box Life Day Christmas

2022 Disney Star Wars Blue Milk and Cookies Set! New in Box Life Day Christmas

$44.95$22.48

JELLO No Bake OREO DESSERT Mix 12.6 oz Box

JELLO No Bake OREO DESSERT Mix 12.6 oz Box

$26.99$13.49

Spode Christmas Tree Collection Cookies for Santa Plate and Milk Bottle Set, 2

Spode Christmas Tree Collection Cookies for Santa Plate and Milk Bottle Set, 2

$47.49$23.75

Vintage Bunnytail Lane 1994 Milk And Cookies For Easter Set New

Vintage Bunnytail Lane 1994 Milk And Cookies For Easter Set New

$15.89$7.95

Spode Christmas Tree Collection Cookies for Santa Plate and Milk Bottle Set, ...

Spode Christmas Tree Collection Cookies for Santa Plate and Milk Bottle Set, ...

$51.13$25.57

RAE DUNN ARTISAN COLLECTION BY MAGENTA “Milk And Cookies” Set RED

RAE DUNN ARTISAN COLLECTION BY MAGENTA “Milk And Cookies” Set RED

$12.58$6.29

Winnie-the-Pooh Cookies and Milk Set for Santa. Disney Story Circa 1999

Winnie-the-Pooh Cookies and Milk Set for Santa. Disney Story Circa 1999

$40.00$20.00

Vtg Christmas Ceramic Candy Star Shaped Plate & Mug. Milk & Cookies. Pinecones

Vtg Christmas Ceramic Candy Star Shaped Plate & Mug. Milk & Cookies. Pinecones

$26.25$13.13

Santa's cookie plate and milk cup home made

Santa's cookie plate and milk cup home made

$16.00$8.00

NORTH POLE TRADING CO. COOKIES AND MILK FOR SANTA SET PLATE & CUP NEW

NORTH POLE TRADING CO. COOKIES AND MILK FOR SANTA SET PLATE & CUP NEW

$24.00$12.00

HEARTH AND HAND WITH MAGNOLIA MILK & COOKIES PLATE & MUG SET FOR SANTA NEW

HEARTH AND HAND WITH MAGNOLIA MILK & COOKIES PLATE & MUG SET FOR SANTA NEW

$28.49$14.24

Vintage Disney Mickeys Santa's Workshop “Cookie And Milk” Plastic Plate and cup

Vintage Disney Mickeys Santa's Workshop “Cookie And Milk” Plastic Plate and cup

$19.99$9.99

“ Department 56 “ 2 Piece Christmas Small Snack Set w/Santa Claus Milk & Cookies

“ Department 56 “ 2 Piece Christmas Small Snack Set w/Santa Claus Milk & Cookies

$14.99$7.50

Longaberger Snowmen SLEIGH BELLE & CHILLY Cookies & Milk For Santa Plate+Cup*EXC

Longaberger Snowmen SLEIGH BELLE & CHILLY Cookies & Milk For Santa Plate+Cup*EXC

$9.95$4.97

CHRISTMAS SANTA'S MILK AND COOKIES (1) PLATE (2) MUGS GOLD STAR COST PLUS

CHRISTMAS SANTA'S MILK AND COOKIES (1) PLATE (2) MUGS GOLD STAR COST PLUS

$15.98$7.99

Vintage Warner Bros. Milk & Cookies for Santa Plate & Mug, Sylvester and Tweety

Vintage Warner Bros. Milk & Cookies for Santa Plate & Mug, Sylvester and Tweety

$22.00$11.00

Norman Rockwell's "Santa Eating Cookies and Milk" Collectors Plate w/COA

Norman Rockwell's "Santa Eating Cookies and Milk" Collectors Plate w/COA

$15.00$7.50

Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Supplies Set Plates Napkins Cups Tableware Ki...

Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Supplies Set Plates Napkins Cups Tableware Ki...

$31.30$15.65

96Pcs Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Supplies Chocolate Chip Cookies and Mil...

96Pcs Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Supplies Chocolate Chip Cookies and Mil...

$30.01$15.01

Rae Dunn COOKIES and MILK Ceramic Round Plate & Mug Set Christmas NEW '19

Rae Dunn COOKIES and MILK Ceramic Round Plate & Mug Set Christmas NEW '19

$28.00$14.00

Rae Dunn COOKIES and MILK Ceramic Round Plate & Mug Set Christmas NEW '19

Rae Dunn COOKIES and MILK Ceramic Round Plate & Mug Set Christmas NEW '19

$39.95$19.98

Grinch Dr. Seuss 12 Cocoas Ornament Boxed Gift Cookies And Milk Set Grinch Gifts

Grinch Dr. Seuss 12 Cocoas Ornament Boxed Gift Cookies And Milk Set Grinch Gifts

$49.00$24.50

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry, Cardinal Salt & Pepper, Mug/Bear, Plat, Cookies/Milk

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry, Cardinal Salt & Pepper, Mug/Bear, Plat, Cookies/Milk

$15.98$7.99

Cookies and Milk for Santa Plate and Mug Christmas Holiday Set

Cookies and Milk for Santa Plate and Mug Christmas Holiday Set

$19.99$9.99

Santa's cookie plate and milk cup home made

Santa's cookie plate and milk cup home made

$8.00$4.00

handmade believe in the magic of christmas cookie and milk plate

handmade believe in the magic of christmas cookie and milk plate

$15.00$7.50

VTG Santa Milk and Cookie Set ROYAL MAJESTIC FINE CHINA NOEL 8401

VTG Santa Milk and Cookie Set ROYAL MAJESTIC FINE CHINA NOEL 8401

$9.00$4.50

RARE American Dairy Rockwell Santa Eating Milk and Cookies Christmas Plate 1980s

RARE American Dairy Rockwell Santa Eating Milk and Cookies Christmas Plate 1980s

$9.00$4.50

East West Dist Co 8” Christmas COOKIES FOR SANTA Plate 🍪 Children • Red & White

East West Dist Co 8” Christmas COOKIES FOR SANTA Plate 🍪 Children • Red & White

$14.95$7.47

New Santa Snack Plate & Milk Jar 2 Pc. Set Santa's Cookie Plate Glass

New Santa Snack Plate & Milk Jar 2 Pc. Set Santa's Cookie Plate Glass

$21.99$10.99

Hearth & Hand Magnolia Milk & Cookies Plate & Mug Dinnerware Set Joanna NEW

Hearth & Hand Magnolia Milk & Cookies Plate & Mug Dinnerware Set Joanna NEW

$31.32$15.66

Disney Mickey & Minnie Cookies and Milk Platter Set Zak! Design Porcelain w/ Box

Disney Mickey & Minnie Cookies and Milk Platter Set Zak! Design Porcelain w/ Box

$19.99$9.99

Dear God Melamine Christmas Serving Plate and Cup Tree Dog Cookie and Milk

Dear God Melamine Christmas Serving Plate and Cup Tree Dog Cookie and Milk

$21.99$10.99

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Cookies and Milk for Santa Set 9" Plate and 12oz Mug, NE

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Cookies and Milk for Santa Set 9" Plate and 12oz Mug, NE

$29.97$14.98

Hallmark Holiday Santa Snack Set 7.5” Cookie Plate and Milk Jug w/Cute Snowmen!

Hallmark Holiday Santa Snack Set 7.5” Cookie Plate and Milk Jug w/Cute Snowmen!

$19.34$9.67

Longaberger Pottery Milk And Cookies for Santa Set Of Plate & Tumbler Christmas

Longaberger Pottery Milk And Cookies for Santa Set Of Plate & Tumbler Christmas

$20.00$10.00

Kids Christmas Cookies and Milk for Santa Plate and Mug Cup 3D Hand Painted

Kids Christmas Cookies and Milk for Santa Plate and Mug Cup 3D Hand Painted

$17.90$8.95

Milk and Cookies Stitchery Frame

Milk and Cookies Stitchery Frame

$21.99$10.99

handmade santa is coming to town cookie and milk plate

handmade santa is coming to town cookie and milk plate

$15.00$7.50

1996 Warner Bros. Milk & Cookies for Santa Plate & Mug, Sylvester and Tweety

1996 Warner Bros. Milk & Cookies for Santa Plate & Mug, Sylvester and Tweety

$49.99$25.00

FAO Schwarz 2 Piece Santa's Milk and Cookie Set New in Package

FAO Schwarz 2 Piece Santa's Milk and Cookie Set New in Package

$28.00$14.00

St. Nicholas Square 'Cookies For Santa' Plate, Milk Bottle, and Straw Set - NEW

St. Nicholas Square 'Cookies For Santa' Plate, Milk Bottle, and Straw Set - NEW

$14.99$7.50

Milk and Cookies ~ Santa Disney Happy Holidays! Disney World, Swell!

Milk and Cookies ~ Santa Disney Happy Holidays! Disney World, Swell!

$27.00$13.50

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Cookies and Milk for Santa Set Plate and Mug NIB

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Cookies and Milk for Santa Set Plate and Mug NIB

$41.25$20.63

Hearth & Home with Magnolia Milk & Cookies Plate and Mug Set for Santa NEW NIB

Hearth & Home with Magnolia Milk & Cookies Plate and Mug Set for Santa NEW NIB

$19.95$9.97

Rae Dunn COOKIES and MILK Santa Melamine Round Plate & Mug Set

Rae Dunn COOKIES and MILK Santa Melamine Round Plate & Mug Set

$17.95$8.97

Frankenstein Halloween Mug And Plate Set Cookies & Milk Ghosts Goblins VINTAGE

Frankenstein Halloween Mug And Plate Set Cookies & Milk Ghosts Goblins VINTAGE

$15.99$8.00

Hearth and Hand Magnolia Plate and Mug Dinnerware Set Cookies and Milk Farmhouse

Hearth and Hand Magnolia Plate and Mug Dinnerware Set Cookies and Milk Farmhouse

$46.00$23.00

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Christmas Cookies For Santa Snack Plate and Milk Mug

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Christmas Cookies For Santa Snack Plate and Milk Mug

$38.99$19.50

PFALTZGRAFF SANTA’S MILK AND COOKIES DISH TRAY CHRISTMAS SERVING PLATE RED BOW

PFALTZGRAFF SANTA’S MILK AND COOKIES DISH TRAY CHRISTMAS SERVING PLATE RED BOW

$12.40$6.20

Warner Bros. Milk & Cookies for Santa Plate & Mug, Sylvester and Tweety

Warner Bros. Milk & Cookies for Santa Plate & Mug, Sylvester and Tweety

$20.00$10.00

Candy Cane Kitchen Milk & Cookies Gift Set Demdaco Christmas Cookie Plate, Mug

Candy Cane Kitchen Milk & Cookies Gift Set Demdaco Christmas Cookie Plate, Mug

$25.00$12.50

Pottery Barn Teddy Bear Milk and Cookie set for St. Jude Children Hos. NIB

Pottery Barn Teddy Bear Milk and Cookie set for St. Jude Children Hos. NIB

$34.99$17.50

Rae Dunn HO HO HO SANTA Plate and Mug Set cookie and milk For Santa NEW

Rae Dunn HO HO HO SANTA Plate and Mug Set cookie and milk For Santa NEW

$17.99$8.99

Custom Santa Tray, Christmas Eve Cookie Board, Milk and Cookies for Santa Plate,

Custom Santa Tray, Christmas Eve Cookie Board, Milk and Cookies for Santa Plate,

$44.99$22.50

handmade santa cookie and milk plate

handmade santa cookie and milk plate

$15.00$7.50

Joseph Holodook Ceramic Santa Milk Glass & Cookie Plate Merry Christmas Santa

Joseph Holodook Ceramic Santa Milk Glass & Cookie Plate Merry Christmas Santa

$29.95$14.97

Tiny Ideas Santa’s Cookie and Milk Set Chalk Plate Christmas / Holiday

Tiny Ideas Santa’s Cookie and Milk Set Chalk Plate Christmas / Holiday

$14.00$7.00

Jack Frost My Very Own Milk and Cookies for Santa Set NIB

Jack Frost My Very Own Milk and Cookies for Santa Set NIB

$19.99$9.99

Joseph Holodook Ceramic Santa Milk Glass & Cookie Plate Merry Christmas Santa

Joseph Holodook Ceramic Santa Milk Glass & Cookie Plate Merry Christmas Santa

$19.99$9.99

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Cookies & Milk for Santa Set 9" Plate and 12oz Mug, NIB

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Cookies & Milk for Santa Set 9" Plate and 12oz Mug, NIB

$24.90$12.45

Vintage 1995 MARY ENGELBREIT Santa's Milk & Cookies Set Plate and Mug Christmas

Vintage 1995 MARY ENGELBREIT Santa's Milk & Cookies Set Plate and Mug Christmas

$19.99$9.99

Star Wars Up to Snow Good Santa Blue Cookie Plate and Milk Glass

Star Wars Up to Snow Good Santa Blue Cookie Plate and Milk Glass

$20.00$10.00

FITZ AND FLOYD Holiday Mug & Plate Set Reindeer w/Candy Cane Santa Milk & Cookie

FITZ AND FLOYD Holiday Mug & Plate Set Reindeer w/Candy Cane Santa Milk & Cookie

$24.97$12.48

RAE DUNN Christmas Santa MILK Mug COOKIES Plate Set white Snacks Tea Coffee Cup

RAE DUNN Christmas Santa MILK Mug COOKIES Plate Set white Snacks Tea Coffee Cup

$18.00$9.00

Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Supplies - Milk and Cookies Party Decorations...

Milk and Cookies Birthday Party Supplies - Milk and Cookies Party Decorations...

$30.61$15.30

Holt Howard 1962 Plate And Cup Santa Vintage Christmas Milk And Cookies

Holt Howard 1962 Plate And Cup Santa Vintage Christmas Milk And Cookies

$100.00$50.00

Hearth and Hand Magnolia Plate and Mug Dinnerware Set Cookies and Milk Farmhouse

Hearth and Hand Magnolia Plate and Mug Dinnerware Set Cookies and Milk Farmhouse

$49.99$25.00

Bunnytail Lane Milk and Cookies for Easter Bunny

Bunnytail Lane Milk and Cookies for Easter Bunny

$9.99$5.00

Vintage Floral Biscuit Barrel Satin Milk Glass and Silverplate Cookie Jar

Vintage Floral Biscuit Barrel Satin Milk Glass and Silverplate Cookie Jar

$105.00$52.50

Vintage Disney's Candy Cane Christmas 2000 Cookies and Milk for Santa Plate Mug

Vintage Disney's Candy Cane Christmas 2000 Cookies and Milk for Santa Plate Mug

$19.99$9.99

Disney’s Candy Cane Christmas 2000 Cookies and Milk for Santa Plate & Mug Y2k

Disney’s Candy Cane Christmas 2000 Cookies and Milk for Santa Plate & Mug Y2k

$22.00$11.00

Hearth and Hand Magnolia Mug ONLY Cookies and Milk Farmhouse

Hearth and Hand Magnolia Mug ONLY Cookies and Milk Farmhouse

$9.99$5.00

Longaberger Cookies and milk Plate and Tumbler 1998 Snowman for Santa

Longaberger Cookies and milk Plate and Tumbler 1998 Snowman for Santa

$39.99$20.00

Pier 1 Santa's Milk & Cookies Mug and Plate

Pier 1 Santa's Milk & Cookies Mug and Plate

$10.00$5.00

Hearth & Hand with Magnolia Milk and Cookies Plate & Mug NEW!

Hearth & Hand with Magnolia Milk and Cookies Plate & Mug NEW!

$49.99$25.00

NEW Vtg Lucy And Me Santas Cookies And Milk Melamine Snack Set Enesco '91 Sealed

NEW Vtg Lucy And Me Santas Cookies And Milk Melamine Snack Set Enesco '91 Sealed

$30.00$15.00

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Milk & Cookies for Santa Mug & Plate Boxed Set

Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Milk & Cookies for Santa Mug & Plate Boxed Set

$19.99$9.99

Oneida Snow Pals Snowman Lights Candy Cane Mug & Plate Santa Cookies and Milk

Oneida Snow Pals Snowman Lights Candy Cane Mug & Plate Santa Cookies and Milk

$24.97$12.48

Milk And Cookies Birthday Party Supplies Set Plates Napkins Cups Tableware Kit F

Milk And Cookies Birthday Party Supplies Set Plates Napkins Cups Tableware Kit F

$28.69$14.35

Vintage Longaberger 1998 Milk And Cookies For Santa Gift Set

Vintage Longaberger 1998 Milk And Cookies For Santa Gift Set

$30.00$15.00

2022 Disney Parks Star Wars Blue Milk and Cookies For Santa Ewok Set New

2022 Disney Parks Star Wars Blue Milk and Cookies For Santa Ewok Set New

$49.99$25.00

New Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Cookies & Milk for Santa Set Plate & Mug

New Pfaltzgraff Winterberry Cookies & Milk for Santa Set Plate & Mug

$31.99$15.99

Star Wars 2-Piece Porcelain CHRISTMAS Milk and Cookies Set

Star Wars 2-Piece Porcelain CHRISTMAS Milk and Cookies Set

$16.99$8.49

(A) Starbucks Coffee Bearista Grande Adventure Holiday Milk & Cookies Mug Plate

(A) Starbucks Coffee Bearista Grande Adventure Holiday Milk & Cookies Mug Plate

$14.50$7.25

Rae Dunn Milk and Cookie Gift Set Milk Mug Cookies Plate

Rae Dunn Milk and Cookie Gift Set Milk Mug Cookies Plate

$29.99$14.99

Christmas Santa Cookie Hot Chocolate Milk Mug Cup & Plate Snowman Holiday

Christmas Santa Cookie Hot Chocolate Milk Mug Cup & Plate Snowman Holiday

$25.00$12.50

Disney Store Pooh's Season Of Song 1997 Cookies And Milk Plate & Mug Set

Disney Store Pooh's Season Of Song 1997 Cookies And Milk Plate & Mug Set

$29.99$14.99

96Pcs Milk and Cookies 1st Birthday Party Supplies Milk and Cookies Party Pap...

96Pcs Milk and Cookies 1st Birthday Party Supplies Milk and Cookies Party Pap...

$28.65$14.32